I agree with my previous speakers - really tough choice this week.
ParkinsonismBig improvement! Good usability achieved through reasonable colour scheme and also reasonable and attractive background image manipulation. Nice design of the respective highlights, especially Grid Highlight is a beauty. Good icon set. Way to go. Cosmetics: Silver Surfer image on popups gets distorted the bigger a popup becomes, the white dots on the left and right of the popup are a bit too much and make the popup look messy.
NVDVS1Cool wally, nice colour scheme and a refreshing icon set. Good usability except turquoise text on the highlights could be brighter as it doesn't stand out enough from the brown.
LonghairsteffI'm impressed by how you constantly come up with such quality themes. Very well done again.
Happyyesh Neat and quite usable, looks good with Moncc's friendly icons. Cool analogue clock face. List highlight sometimes a bit hard to tell from the background, would be better with e.g. a thin light grey line at the top and bottom.
sam1374Hehe, where did you find those icons
You worked your way through Carbide UI quite good this week. The theme is attractive and highly usable. Nice design idea to use a drop shadow on the highlights.
galmed A good idea with the transparent blue layer on the submenue images, that gives an "underwater" look that matches "Nemo" quite well. Funny icon set. Red softkey text in the submenues is a bit uneasy on the eyes, imho a dark blue tone would've been better.
cute_heartCrisp theme with good usability and nice animation. Softkey and statusbar design could be more exciting (as e.g. the really nice softkeys in your "Flower" theme). Two little flaws: The date text on the Idle Screen (Idle > Idle Screen > Colors > Idle Font Colour) is black on black background, would be better in a brighter colour. And the calendar colours are black on dark background and therefore hard to read. In general, I recommend lightening up the calendar backgrounds, as on older S40 phones, the colour of the calendar numbers can't be changed and they're always shown black.
MissCharmingHeartPleasant caramel colour scheme, I like the "soft" look of the highlights very much. Baby icons are a witty idea, although a bit irritating as they're all identical. A transparent layer in a light colour would be good for the calendar backgrounds as some numbers are hard to see, especially those above the baby's eyes.
AnujText in the submenue is a bit hard to read, a dark transparent layer would be good. Icons are nice but a bit small.
findgirl45I downloaded your theme but it didn't work on the phone. I assume you accidentally saved it with the "Series40 Theme v3.0 light" option at the end of the theming process in Carbide UI. As a result, one can only see the text colours of your theme on the phone, but most of the pictures are missing.
The correct option for a Symbian Series 40 3d Edition 240x320 theme would be "Series40 Theme v2.0":
If you make a copy of your theme (via "Save as..." in Carbide UI) and then save it with the "Series40 Theme v2.0"option, everything should be fine and you could upload your theme again. You can find more info about the correct saving options for Series 40 themes at the beginning of
this post
(Or maybe you used svg graphics in your theme - many S40 phones can't read them properly.)
Anyway, as I can tell fom the screenshot, your theme looks quite usable; icons are a bit bulky, could be smaller to look more elegant.
. I hope I will be invited to judge future competitions as well!
..it's so many elements to think of, it's not easy but keep up! 
Thank you, thank you!!
