1: Bishop Bacon
2: lilithbloody
3: sg
I just don't have time to give comments to each and every one! But a few suggestions at least:
@lilithbloody
[attachmentid=13963]
Great work and this is the only thing I might have done differently. The sword gets too bright at the bottom imo. You could have darkened it to match the upper part which would have made the text more readable.
@HOCKEY
Very close to a vote with this great looking theme. I just wish you would have made all screens big!
@wraithevolution
[attachmentid=13964]
A nice effort, but in my book this is a no-no.. I think you should try to avoid very bright and very dark bits where the text is placed. It makes it almost impossible to make a user-friendly theme.
And to get the most from your preview, save it as png.
@lilith485
Very nice, but same as above, please use png instead of jpg. It will do wonders!
@all
Great work, guys!

Almost all of you use jpg for your previews and some has used low compression which makes it ok, but there is no real reason not to use png if you use imageshack and the likes. The images will not be too big to upload and the quality is so much better. Jpg is a destructive format and I would kill it if I could!
As a general recommendation; In the finishing stages of your theme-making, take some time to check the functionality of your theme and take whatever steps necessary to make it as functional as possible.